Positioning, Navigation and Timing (PNT) - alternative to GPS navigation

GPS is essential for modern life but vulnerable to interference. Alternative positioning, navigation and timing (PNT) systems are necessary for reliability. Global Positioning System (GPS) technology has become deeply integrated into modern life and determines how we navigate and understand our modern world. Originally developed by the US Department of Defence for military purposes, GPS is now used by almost everyone - from dedicated hikers and car drivers to aviation and maritime professionals.

But our heavy reliance on this technology has led to concerns about what happens when GPS fails, whether due to technical failures, malicious attacks or natural phenomena. Consequently, it has become increasingly important to recognise our dependence on GPS and explore alternative navigation systems such as Positioning, Navigation and Timing (PNT).

The wide range of uses and benefits of GPS

GPS technology has become so integrated into our lives that it is easy to overlook its impact. It is the invisible force that guides us turn-by-turn through unfamiliar streets, ensures food deliveries arrive on time and even helps farmers optimise harvests.

Beyond personal convenience, GPS is a fundamental part of critical infrastructure. It enables accurate time measurement for financial transactions, synchronises large communication networks and enables efficient supply chain management.

TransportationIn the transport sector, GPS navigation systems have revolutionised the way we travel, offering real-time traffic updates, optimised routes and even parking assistance. GPS tracking systems have transformed the logistics industry, providing businesses and consumers with precise location information for parcels, ensuring on-time deliveries and minimising losses.

Finance: The financial sector is another area where GPS plays a crucial role. Accurate time stamping is essential for financial transactions, and GPS signals are the gold standard for time synchronisation in global markets. In addition, GPS is crucial for synchronising mobile networks and electricity grids, ensuring seamless communication and stable energy distribution.

From personal navigation to global trade and infrastructure management, GPS is the silent force driving our modern world. Its ubiquity and versatility underline its importance in shaping different aspects of our lives, making it an indispensable technology in our increasingly interconnected society.

GPS's Achilles heel: Vulnerability to interference

However, the widespread use of GPS also brings vulnerabilities. GPS signals, which come from satellites thousands of miles above the Earth, are surprisingly weak when they reach our receivers. This inherent weakness makes them susceptible to both natural and man-made interference.

Solar storms, for example, can cause major damage to these signals, disrupting everything from navigation systems to financial transactions. Even more worrying is the threat of deliberate interference. Jamming - deliberate blocking of signals - and spoofing - sending false signals - can create widespread chaos.

The ongoing conflict in Ukraine is a clear example of these vulnerabilities. Reports of GPS disruptions have emphasised the potential for adversaries to exploit this weakness, with potentially catastrophic consequences for military operations, critical infrastructure and civilian life. The vulnerability of GPS to such threats underlines the need for a robust backup plan - one that includes diversified navigation capabilities.

PNT solutions: Navigating beyond GPS

Let us examine the current situation, the challenges and the potential for wider application of different PNT technologies:

1. GNSS (Global Navigation Satellite Systems):

• Current status: Several GNSS constellations are fully operational (GPS, GLONASS, Galileo, BeiDou) and offer wide coverage and redundancy. The technology is mature and well established, with continuous advances in accuracy, signal processing and receiver performance.
• Challenges: Continued sensitivity to signal interference, jamming and spoofing, especially in military and critical infrastructure applications. The high cost of launching and maintaining satellites is also a barrier for new providers.
• Potential for wider use: GNSS is already used in many industrial and consumer applications. Future developments focus on improving accuracy, signal robustness and integration with other PNT technologies for seamless and reliable positioning.

2. eLoran:

• Current status: Although operational in some regions, eLoran requires significant infrastructure investment for global use. Ongoing efforts focus on modernising existing infrastructure and expanding coverage.
• Challenges: The costs of implementing and maintaining eLoran transmitter stations are significant. Although the system is considered more robust than GNSS, there are still concerns about interference.
• Potential for wider use: eLoran has the potential to serve as a reliable and cost-effective backup for GPS, especially in maritime and aeronautical applications and for critical infrastructure applications.

3. Inertial navigation systems (INS):

• Current status: INS technology has evolved significantly, with smaller, more accurate and affordable sensors. It is widely used in aeronautical, maritime and military applications, often in combination with GNSS.
• Challenges: High-performance INSs can still be expensive for some applications. Despite advanced algorithms, sensor drift is a limitation for long-term autonomous navigation.
• Potential for wider use: INS is increasingly being integrated with other PNT systems, such as GNSS and visual odometry, to provide highly accurate and reliable positioning for autonomous vehicles, robots and other applications that require precise navigation in GPS-free environments.

4. Astronomical navigation:

• Current status: Modernised astronomical navigation systems are available and include automation and advanced algorithms for improved accuracy. However, their use is limited to specific applications, such as long-distance travel and scientific research.
• Challenges: The need for clear visibility and precise time measurement pose challenges for consistent and reliable use. In addition, the complexity of astronomical navigation and the lack of broad expertise can hinder its wider use.
• Potential for wider use: With technological advances and sophisticated automation, astronomical navigation may become more accessible and useful as a backup to GPS.

5. Quantum clocks:

• Current status: Quantum clocks are still in the research and development phase, with significant progress being made in laboratory environments. Miniaturisation and commercialisation are ongoing.
• Challenges: Quantum clocks are currently complex, expensive and require specialised environments to operate. Overcoming these challenges is crucial for their wider use.
• Potential for wider use: Quantum clocks have enormous potential to revolutionise PNT by offering unprecedented time accuracy. This could lead to more precise navigation and improved synchronisation of critical infrastructure.

Examples of PNT solutions in practice

The growing awareness of GPS vulnerabilities has led to innovation and adoption of alternative PNT systems in various sectors, especially in the military. Here are some compelling examples of how organisations are leveraging these technologies to ensure robust navigation and timing:

• U.S. Coast Guard: eLoran Implementation for Maritime Security
  In recognition of GPS limitations in coastal navigation, the U.S. Coast Guard has been actively developing and testing eLoran as a complementary system. eLoran's strong signal and terrestrial nature make it less susceptible to interference, providing a reliable backup for navigation and positioning in critical maritime operations.
• Airservices Australia: Improving flight safety with a multi-layer PNT system
  Airservices Australia, the country's air navigation service provider, has implemented a comprehensive PNT strategy that combines GNSS with ground-based augmentation systems and inertial navigation systems (INS). This multi-layered approach improves the accuracy and reliability of aircraft navigation, ensuring safer flights and minimising interference caused by GPS outages.
• John Deere: Pioneer in precision agriculture with GPS and INS integration
  Agricultural equipment manufacturer John Deere has integrated GPS and INS into its tractors and other agricultural machinery. This integration enables precise navigation and positioning, allowing farmers to optimise their operations, reduce input costs and increase yields. The INS component ensures continuous operation even in areas with poor GPS reception or during temporary outages.
• London Stock Exchange: Reinforcing the financial market infrastructure with atomic clocks
  To ensure the accuracy and integrity of high-frequency trading, the London Stock Exchange has invested in a network of atomic clocks that provide precise time synchronisation across its trading platforms. This investment has improved the exchange's operational reliability and reduced the risk of errors or manipulation resulting from time discrepancies.
• Norway's eLoran network: A national backup for critical infrastructure
  Norway has established a national eLoran network to provide a reliable backup for GPS in critical infrastructure sectors such as transport, energy and telecommunications. This investment demonstrates a proactive approach to mitigating the risks of GPS dependency and ensuring continuity of essential services in the event of disruptions.

These real-world examples highlight the versatile applications and benefits of PNT systems. By adopting these technologies, organisations can improve safety, increase efficiency and protect critical operations from GPS vulnerabilities. As the demand for reliable and robust navigation and timing solutions continues to grow, PNT systems will play an increasingly important role in our interconnected world.

Final words on PNT vs GPS

In conclusion, while GPS has become a reliable and almost ubiquitous part of our lives, it is crucial to guard against the risks of relying too much on a single system.

The exploration and development of alternative PNT systems, which can apply precise corrections for course orientation by combining GPS applications, GPS devices, GPS receivers, GPS satellites and navigation satellite systems (GNSS) to receive and interpret navigation signals in real time from any location in the world, can provide robustness. This ensures that even if one component fails, other components can smoothly take over and prevent costly interruptions. These alternative systems can provide absolute corrections to achieve precise and accurate time and location data.

As technology evolves and our dependence on GPS grows, PNI Sensor is leading the effort to create and make available effective PNT systems to add layers of safety and pave the way for innovations and improvements across all sectors of society.

Don't let your business or critical operations be caught off guard by GPS vulnerabilities. Explore PNI Sensor's range of PNT solutions to ensure robustness and continuity of your navigation needs. Contact us today for a consultation and discover how we can customise a PNT solution to protect your operations and drive you forward in the future of navigation technology.

This is a translated article from our partner NIBP Sensor.

Want to know more?

Contact us at ACTE.